Canning cucumbers from an Appalachian homestead in West Virginia, white yucca blooms along the river in late spring
|

Canning Cucumbers: How I Preserved 72 English Cucumbers Before They Went Bad

This post contains affiliate links. I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

A semi truck pulled up to our little church in War, West Virginia and dropped off hundreds of boxes of English cucumbers. Just like that, our town of 500 people had a cucumber situation on our hands. Trey came home with six boxes, which meant I had 72 cucumbers sitting on my counter with a clock ticking. The boxes were dated May 18th and it was already May 24th. Canning cucumbers was about to become my full time job for the next few days.

Multiple boxes of Sunset greenhouse English cucumbers spread across a West Virginia homestead kitchen floor

Canning Cucumbers: Can You Use English Cucumbers?

Yes, but not for every method. This is the question I heard most from the women at church that day and the honest answer is that English cucumbers are a little different from your standard pickling cucumber. They have thinner skins and a much higher water content, which means they do not hold up the way a Kirby or a traditional pickling cucumber does.

Here is what that means in practice. If you try to make classic dill pickle spears with English cucumbers using a water bath canning method, you are going to end up with soft, mushy pickles. The thin skin just cannot hold that satisfying crunch that makes a dill pickle worth eating. Refrigerator dill pickles are a different story. Because you skip the heat processing, the cucumbers stay firmer and actually work beautifully.

For bread and butter pickles, relish and freeze dried chips, English cucumbers are genuinely great. The high water content is not a problem for these methods because the process accounts for it. You salt them first to draw out the excess moisture, and from there they hold up perfectly through the canning or freeze drying process.

So can you pickle English cucumbers? Yes. You just need to match the right method to the cucumber. Everything in this post is specifically designed to work with English cucumbers, so if that is what you have, you are in the right place.

What To Do With Too Many Cucumbers

When you are staring down 72 cucumbers with a six day clock on them, you stop asking what sounds fun and start asking what actually works. Here is every method I used to get through the whole haul with nothing going to waste.

Dozens of labeled jars of bread and butter pickles, sweet relish and dill relish spread across a dining table after preserving a large haul of English cucumbers

Refrigerator Dill Pickles: The fastest method and the best option if you want that classic dill pickle flavor with English cucumbers. No water bath needed and ready to eat in 24 to 48 hours.

Bread and Butter Pickles: Sweet, tangy and water bath canned for shelf stable storage. I made 24 pints from this haul alone. These are genuinely beginner friendly and one of the most satisfying things to pull off a pantry shelf in the middle of winter.

Homemade Relish: I made three kinds, dill relish, sweet relish and a sweet and spicy version using ghost pepper powder we grew and freeze dried ourselves. All three are water bath canned and the process is nearly identical across all of them.

Freeze Dried Cucumber Chips: Plain and ranch seasoned, straight into the freeze dryer for long term storage. This was my most creative use of the haul and honestly one of my favorites.

Way 1: Refrigerator Dill Pickles with English Cucumbers

Two large mason jars of refrigerator dill pickles made with English cucumber spears and fresh dill

Refrigerator dill pickles are the best method for English cucumbers if you want that classic dill pickle experience. Because you skip the water bath entirely, the cucumbers never go through the heat that turns them soft and mushy. What you get instead are crisp, garlicky, herby spears that taste like they came from a deli counter. I packed mine into wide mouth quart jars with fresh dill, red pepper flakes and whole peppercorns and had pickles ready to eat the next day.

The brine comes together in about five minutes on the stove and the whole process from start to finished jar takes less than 30 minutes. There is no special equipment, no water bath canner and no processing time. If you have never preserved anything before in your life, this is where I would tell you to start.

These do live in the refrigerator rather than on a pantry shelf, so they are not shelf stable the way water bath canned pickles are. But honestly in our house they never last long enough to matter. Unless of course you have 72 cucumbers to preserve, in which case you are going to need to get a lot more creative than refrigerator pickles alone. Keep reading.

Refrigerator Dill Pickles with English Cucumbers blog

Way 2: Bread and Butter Pickles

Four pint jars of homemade bread and butter pickles cooling on a kitchen towel after water bath canning
Jar lifter pulling a pint jar of bread and butter pickles from a water bath canner

Bread and butter pickles are where English cucumbers really shine. The salting step at the beginning draws out all that extra water content, which means by the time your cucumbers hit the brine they are ready to absorb all that sweet tangy flavor without turning to mush. I ended up with 24 pints from this batch and every single jar sealed perfectly.

This is also the method I recommend most for beginners who want to try water bath canning for the first time. The process is straightforward, the ingredients are simple and the result is something you will actually use. Bread and butter pickles go on sandwiches, burgers, charcuterie boards and straight out of the jar at midnight. I am not judging.

You will need a water bath canner, wide mouth pint jars, canning lids and pickling salt to get started. I have linked everything I used below so you are not hunting around trying to figure out what to buy. The Supa Ant 21 Qt Water Bath Canning Pot is what I use and it comes with the rack, a ladle, measuring cups and a canning funnel so you have everything in one kit.

Bread and Butter Pickles with English cucumbers blog.

Way 3: Homemade Relish Three Ways

Vegetable chopper dicing English cucumbers into small pieces for homemade cucumber relish
Pint jars of homemade sweet relish with red pepper and mustard seed cooling on a kitchen towel

This is where things got fun. I made three kinds of relish from this haul: dill relish, sweet relish and a sweet and spicy version that I am honestly still thinking about. The process for all three is nearly identical. You dice the cucumbers, salt them to draw out the water, drain them and then cook them down in a seasoned brine before packing them into jars for water bath canning.

The dill relish is bright and tangy, exactly what you want on a hot dog or mixed into a potato salad. The sweet relish uses apple cider vinegar instead of white vinegar which gives it a slightly deeper, warmer flavor. And the sweet and spicy version, well, that one has a story attached to it that deserves its own blog post. What I will tell you here is that the heat comes from ghost pepper powder we grew ourselves, freeze dried and very carefully bottled. Last year’s church donation of peppers showing up in this year’s cucumber relish is exactly the kind of full circle moment that makes homesteading feel like it actually means something.

The Mueller Pro Chopper made dicing 72 cucumbers infinitely more manageable. I also used the Dash Safe Slice Mandoline for the slicing portions of this project and both tools earned a permanent spot in my canning kitchen after this week.

Dill Relish blog.

Sweet Relish and Sweet and Spicy Relish blog.

Way 4: Freeze Dried Cucumber Chips

English cucumbers sliced to quarter inch thickness on a mandoline slicer ready for freeze drying
Freeze dryer trays loaded with ranch seasoned English cucumber slices before freeze drying
Trays of fully freeze dried plain English cucumber chips after coming out of the freeze dryer

This one surprised me. I went into it thinking freeze dried cucumber chips would be a fine way to use up the extras. I came out the other side genuinely obsessed with them. Plain, ranch seasoned and a spicy version using our homemade ghost pepper powder. All three went into the freeze dryer and came out light, crispy and completely shelf stable for long term storage.

The freeze drying process pulls out nearly all the moisture while keeping the flavor and nutrition intact. What you end up with is a chip that rehydrates perfectly if you want it to, or stays crispy straight out of the jar as a snack. My husband has strong opinions about the spicy version and those opinions mostly involve finding excuses to share them with unsuspecting people. That is a story for another day.

If you already have a freeze dryer this is one of the easiest things you will ever run through it. Slice, season if you want, load the trays and let the machine do the rest. The shelf life on freeze dried cucumber chips stored in an airtight container is significantly longer than anything you can achieve with water bath canning, which makes this method worth knowing even if you only have a handful of cucumbers left over after everything else.

Check out my blog on freeze drying cucumbers here.

Easy Canning Recipes for Beginners

If you have never canned anything before and this post has you curious, I want you to know that water bath canning is genuinely one of the most approachable things you can learn in a homestead kitchen. You do not need a pressure canner. You do not need a giant setup. You need a pot deep enough to submerge your jars, a rack to keep them off the bottom, a jar lifter and some basic canning supplies.

Bread and butter pickles and relish are the two methods I would point a brand new canner toward first. The ingredients are simple, the process is forgiving and the results are something you will actually use. There is no guessing about whether something is done. You fill the jars, process them in the water bath, pull them out and listen for that satisfying pop as the lids seal. That pop never gets old, I do not care how many batches you have made.

The Supa Ant 21 Qt Water Bath Canning Pot is what I used for this entire cucumber project. It comes with everything you need to get started including the rack, a ladle, measuring cups and a canning funnel, so you are not piecing together a kit from scratch. The Ball Wide Mouth Pint Jars are what I use for both pickles and relish. Wide mouth makes filling and cleaning significantly easier and pint size is the right portion for most households.

The most important thing I can tell a beginner is this. Follow a tested recipe from a reliable source. I always reference the National Center for Home Food Preservation at nchfp.uga.edu for safe canning guidelines. The recipes in the individual blogs linked in this post are all built around tested ratios so you can can with confidence.

How To Preserve Cucumbers at Home: What I Would Do First

If you just landed here with a pile of cucumbers and no plan, here is exactly what I would do and in what order.

Start with the refrigerator dill pickles. They take less than 30 minutes, require no special equipment and give you something to show for your effort the very next day. They also buy you time because you are moving cucumbers out of their raw state immediately while you figure out your next steps.

Next tackle the bread and butter pickles. This is your biggest shelf stable win and the process is straightforward enough that you can run multiple batches in a single afternoon once you have your canning pot going. I processed 24 pints over two days and it felt completely manageable.

Then move into relish. Relish is actually the most efficient use of cucumbers because the dicing process lets you use cucumbers that are not pretty enough for pickle slices. Irregular shapes, slightly soft spots, cucumbers that got a little too ripe. All of it works perfectly fine in relish. Nothing goes to waste.

Save the freeze dryer for last if you have one. It does not require the same urgency as the other methods since you are controlling the process completely. Load your trays, set your cycle and walk away. It is the most hands off method of everything in this post.

If you do not have a freeze dryer, skip that section for now and focus on the canning methods. Between refrigerator pickles, bread and butter pickles and relish you have more than enough to work through a large haul without wasting a single cucumber.

Dozens of labeled jars of bread and butter pickles, sweet relish and dill relish spread across a dining table after preserving a large haul of English cucumbers

FAQ’s

Can you use English cucumbers for canning?

Yes, but the method matters. English cucumbers have thinner skins and higher water content than traditional pickling cucumbers, which means they do not hold up well for classic water bath canned dill pickles. They work beautifully for refrigerator pickles, bread and butter pickles, relish and freeze dried chips. Match the right method to the cucumber and you will not be disappointed.

Why are my canned cucumbers soft?

Soft canned cucumbers are almost always the result of one of three things. The cucumbers were overripe before you started, you skipped the salting step that draws out excess moisture, or the processing time was too long. English cucumbers are especially prone to softness because of their high water content, which is why the salting step is not optional for any recipe that calls for it.

Do you have to use pickling cucumbers for pickles?

No, but pickling cucumbers give you the best results for classic crunchy dill pickles because of their thicker skins and lower water content. English cucumbers work well for refrigerator pickles, bread and butter pickles and relish. If crunch is your priority, refrigerator pickles are your best option with English cucumbers.

How long do refrigerator pickles last?

Refrigerator pickles made with English cucumbers will last up to four weeks in the refrigerator when stored in a sealed jar. They are at their best in the first two weeks when the cucumbers are still firm and the brine is fresh. Always use a clean utensil when pulling pickles out of the jar to avoid introducing bacteria that shortens their shelf life.

Can you freeze dry cucumbers?

Yes and they turn out better than you might expect. Freeze dried cucumber chips come out light, crispy and shelf stable for long term storage. You can eat them straight from the jar as a snack or rehydrate them. Plain, ranch seasoned and spicy versions all work well in the freeze dryer.

What is the difference between dill relish and sweet relish?

Dill relish uses white vinegar and dill seasoning for a tangy savory flavor. Sweet relish uses apple cider vinegar and sugar for a sweeter, slightly warmer flavor profile. The dicing and salting process is nearly identical for both. The difference is entirely in the brine and seasoning.

How many cucumbers do I need for a batch of relish?

A standard batch of relish uses roughly 4 pounds of cucumbers and yields about 8 to 9 pint jars depending on how finely you dice them and how well you drain the moisture. If you are working with English cucumbers, expect slightly more liquid to drain off during the salting step than you would get with pickling cucumbers.

How long does homemade relish last?

Properly water bath canned relish stored in a cool dark place will last up to one year. Once opened, store it in the refrigerator and use it within four weeks. Always check your seal before opening a jar. If the lid flexes up and down or does not pop when opened, discard it.

How to Store Your Preserved Cucumbers

Storage looks different depending on which method you used, so here is a quick breakdown for each one.

Refrigerator Dill Pickles: Store in a sealed jar in the refrigerator for up to four weeks. No pantry storage for these. They are not shelf stable and need to stay cold from the moment you make them.

Bread and Butter Pickles: Properly sealed water bath canned jars store in a cool dark place like a pantry or basement for up to one year. Once you open a jar, move it to the refrigerator and use it within four weeks. Always check your seal before opening. A lid that flexes or does not pop is a jar to discard.

Homemade Relish: Same storage rules as bread and butter pickles. Sealed jars in a cool dark place for up to one year. Refrigerate after opening and use within four weeks.

Freeze Dried Cucumber Chips: Store in an airtight container or sealed mason jar in a cool dark place. Properly stored freeze dried chips can last significantly longer than water bath canned goods, up to 25 years in ideal conditions with oxygen absorbers. Once you open the container and expose them to humidity, eat them within a few weeks for the best texture.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *